Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tom Kimmerer's avatar

Thank you for this clear, if depressing, analysis. I wonder what you think about independent journalists on Substack. You have spent much of your career as an independent journalist and that has obviously been successful for you. As more journalists establish themelves on Substack, there may be opportunities for collaboration. Perhaps you can collectively hire editors and researchers. I think that is the rich corporate interests that gutted the newspaper business and trivialized broadcast news. Is it possible to rebuild journalism here without the right-wing fat cats that have acquired most of the industry?

It seems to me that science journalism is doing well within the confines of science media like Nature and Science. But we are faced with major challenges of health, climate, and biodiversity that require broader platforms. The public is completely ignorant of science news because they never see it. It is time to rebuild science news.

Postcards From Home's avatar

Aside from the important democracy-local news argument, I would make another case I have not heard, or at least not as often: newspapers help form communities. From high school sports scores to obituaries to what business is opening in the vacant grocery, that’s how people form ties and have something to talk about with their neighbors besides the weather. There are also plenty of stories that may never win anyone Pulitzer Prizes but still need telling.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?